Pitting Corrosion vs. Crevice Corrosion in Stainless Steel: Key Distinctions and Prevention
Published by Kristian Ilasko,
Digital Content Coordinator
Oilfield Technology,
Corrosion in stainless steel components poses significant challenges for oil and gas facilities, particularly in offshore operations where it can cost over $1 billion annually according to AMPP. Proactive identification and differentiation of corrosion types, such as pitting and crevice corrosion, is crucial for implementing appropriate solutions. Understanding the mechanisms behind these common corrosion issues and taking preventative measures can help protect assets from costly failures.
Pitting Corrosion
Pitting Corrosion
Pitting occurs when the protective chromium layer deteriorates, exposing the underlying metal to corrosive solutions. This creates small cavities or pits that can silently compromise a pipe's integrity. Warning signs include:
- Reddish-brown iron oxide deposits
- Visible pit formation
- Higher risk in environments with high chloride levels (like seawater)
- Increased susceptibility at higher temperatures
The damage from pitting can extend deeper than surface observations suggest, potentially leading to wall penetration and leaks. Standing water, especially chloride-bearing water like seawater, significantly increases the risk as evaporation concentrates corrosive elements.
Crevice Corrosion
Cervice Corrosion
While similar in cause to pitting, crevice corrosion occurs in hidden spaces, making detection more challenging. Common locations include:
- Between tubing and supports/clamps
- Between adjacent tubing runs
- Under accumulated dirt and deposits
Crevice corrosion is particularly problematic in offshore applications where seawater can become trapped in tight spaces without an outlet. Unlike pitting corrosion, it occurs at lower temperatures and often remains undetected until component removal reveals the damage.
- Use laboratory testing for Critical Pitting Temperature (CPT) and Critical Crevice Temperature (CCT) following ASTM G48 standards
- Consider 316L stainless steel for basic applications in moderate conditions
- Upgrade to super austenitic (6Mo/6HN) or super duplex (2507) stainless steels for harsh environment
- Consider jacketed tubing and jacketed tubing connectors to help prevent external corrosion
- Advanced materials offer improved corrosion resistance and higher strength ratings
2. System Design and Maintenance
- Avoid placing tubing directly against walls or other tubes
- Consider mixed-material combinations, such as 6Mo tubing with 316L fittings
- Keep surfaces clean and free of standing water
- Implement regular inspection protocols
- Educate maintenance teams on corrosion identification and prevention
3. Environmental Controls
- Monitor and control temperature exposure
- Minimize exposure to chloride-bearing solutions
- Prevent water accumulation on surfaces
- Maintain cleanliness to prevent deposit formation
The choice of materials significantly impacts system longevity. While 316L stainless steel performs adequately in many installations, it may prove insufficient in warm climates or areas with high salt exposure. In such cases, upgrading to super austenitic or super duplex stainless steels can provide the necessary corrosion resistance and pressure ratings.
Successful corrosion prevention requires a comprehensive approach combining proper material selection, careful system design, and regular maintenance. By understanding these corrosion types and implementing appropriate preventive measures, facilities can significantly reduce maintenance costs and extend system life spans.
The key to effective corrosion management lies in educating maintenance teams about material properties, corrosion indicators, and prevention strategies. This knowledge enables early detection and intervention before corrosion can compromise system integrity and lead to costly repairs or replacements.
To find out more about Swagelok click here.
Read the article online at: https://www.oilfieldtechnology.com/special-reports/02122024/pitting-corrosion-vs-crevice-corrosion-in-stainless-steel-key-distinctions-and-prevention/
You might also like
Chevron achieves first oil at Future Growth Project in Kazakhstan
Chevron Corporation has announced that its 50% owned affiliate Tengizchevroil LLP (TCO) has started oil production at its Future Growth Project (FGP) located at the Tengiz oil field in Kazakhstan.